Edward J Kelty ( 1888 - 1967 ) was an American painter. Edward J Kelty s works have been put up for auction numerous times, with realized prices surpassing estimated prices, varying from 750 USD for Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Combined Circus in 2005 to 17500 USD for Group of 7 stellar panoramic photographs in 2015 , based on the size and medium of the artwork.